has devolution undermined the union?

YES

• Problems have not been addressed effectively.
  • West Lothian Question.
• Not enough attention has been paid to the Union's benefits (which are no longer felt.)
• Disputes are possible (no clear rules on conflict resolution or policy coordination.)
• Policy divergence allows for clashes and undermined common welfare rights in the UK.
• Nationalism as a whole, has been increased.
  • Support for Scottish independence is up.
• Unease in England over 'unfair' devolution as we do not…