Evolutionary Psychology Citations in Sociological Theory

?
  • Created by: Beata16
  • Created on: 13-01-22 18:45

The Adapted Mind: Evolutionary Psychology and the Generation of Culture (1992) by Barkow, Cosmides & Tooby

  • Supports evolutionary psychology
  • Notes the link between Darwinism and evo psych
  • Pinker and Bloom cover language (apparently with quite a strong argument - Sterelny 1995
  • Sterelny 1995 notes that Shepard on colour perception and evo psych is also convicing
  • Sterelny argues that others are less convincing, e.g. Profet arguing that morning sickness is to prevent mother eating food poisonous to foetus
  • Sterelny likes book, but says it doesn't explain link between molecular genetics and behaviour as much as it should 

Brown, Laland & Mulder 2009. Bateman's Principles and Human Sex Roles. Trends in Ecology and Evolution

  • Desires are consistent across different peoples and cultures BUT they are also consistently different between men and women (culture doesn't matter for desires, but gender does)
  • This must mean integral desires (as I think superficial differences obviously do exist)

Daly & Wilson 1988

  • Children living with step-parents (especially a step-father) are more likely to die in a family-related homicide than children living with two biological parents
  • This supports evo psych, as that would expect (linking in to the selfish gene theory) that parents want their biological children to succeed more than anyone else
  • However, not the whole picture, as Hamilton, Cheng & Powell 2007 conclude that adoptive parents invest the same in their kids as biological parents in comparable family set-up (two-parent)
  • Daly & Wilson have also been criticised for not considering other explanations, such as family tensions, as step-parents often come into the child's life later on, which could lead to more arguments, for example, as the family bond hasn't been formed
  • Criticised quite strongly, esp by Buller 2005
  • Don't account for a range of factors, including emotional attachment between child and parent/step-parent, poverty, living situation, etc (e.g. if all living in one room, as an extreme, going to have a lot more tension, which could, in extreme cases, make homicide more likely). And other factors (like who are the kind of men likely to become step-fathers, maybe those less able to maintain stable relationships, and who are the women more likely to date them)

Freese, Allen Li, & Wade (2003). The Potential Relevances of Biology to Social Inquiry. Annual Review of Sociology

  • See evo psych as useful
  • Sees sociologists' fear that biological explanations will make sociology unneeded and unimportant as behind a

Comments

No comments have yet been made