Stalin's Five Year Plans: The First Five Year Plan (October 1928- December 1932)
- Created by: _awesome_E
- Created on: 07-01-15 19:59
Ideological Reasons for introducing the first plan
Socialism only possible in highly advanced industrial nations
Russia up to 100 years behind western countries
Stalin believed the revolution should serve the wroking class, not peasants like the NEP
His intention was to replace the 'Bourgeois specialists' (industrial managers during NEP) with 'red specialists' (educated by communists and working class)
Political Reasons for introducing the first plan
'Crash Industrialisation' inspired by collectivisation 'successes'
After winning leadership, Stalin wanted to do one better than Lenin, get a better reputation that Lenin
Stalin was concerned Russia wouldn't be able to defend itself in the event of war
To repel attacks needed to develop iron, steel, oil and coal industries on a grand scale
Economic Reasons for introducing the first plan
Responce to NEP's failure to industrialise Russia
E.g. amount of Iron, Steel and Copper under the NEP were less than that under the Tsar
Russia significantly behind Germany, France and other western countries
The First Five Year Plan
Series of targets, drawn up by government officals working for Gosplan (State Planning Committee)
Gosplan employed 1/2 million bureaucrats, who set targets of every factory, workshops and mill in Russia
All targets were set centrally, with limited knowledge of what they were dealing with
Priorities of the first plan
Favoured heavy industries e.g. iron, coal, steel, oil over consumer goods e.g textiles and food
Stalin's Priorities
Stalin didn't understand industry and agriculture
In Stalin's mind, industrialisation equated to creating a heavy industry
Only visited farmland once, yet regularly visited iron foundries and steel works
Stalin believed the path of industrialization began with heavy industry
Stalin was obssessed with heavy industry, bound up in the desire of creating a strong Russia, aa country of iron and steel
Prized physical and mental strength
Stalin = Man of Steel
Priorities in Foundational Industries
Focusing on heavy industry, attempted to lay the foundations for future industrial development
All industries needed raw materials e.g coal, steel, iron to develop
By mass-producing raw materials it would help to gain more skilled workers
As the majority of Stalin's industrial labour force were unskilled peasants that left the countryside after collectivisation
The peasants were unskilled to the production of complex consumer goods but good at production of large quantities of raw materials
Stalin believed that allowing peasants to gain skills for more sophisticated work e.g textiles
Also would lay the foundations for re-armament in case of war
Though he didn't intend to go to war, he knew Russia had to be ready just in case an invasion occured
Successes of the First Plan
Finished a year early in December 1932, due to its huge success, production of raw materials had increased substaintially and Russia was a more dynamic country
Successes included:
Increasing production
Social mobility
Successes - Increasing Production
Economic growth in Russia up around 14% each year
Remarkable considering the state of depression following wall street crash in America and Europe
Achieved better economic success than Tsarism and the NEP in terms of iron, steel, oil and coal
Successes- Social Mobility
Urban population trebled as peasants moved to cities
Peasants taking unskilled jobs, with existing workers getting promoted
Education reformed, workers encouraged to attend classes on technical subjects, university made avaliable to people with minimal qualifications
Program of 'proletarain advancement' in which got rid of 'bourgeious specialists replacing them with 150,000 newly trained working class 'red specialists'
Failures of the First Plan
Stalin used impressive statistics of increased production in heavy industry as evidence of his wise leadership and the triumpt of socialism
However behind the propanganda was a chaotic economy which struggled to meet targets due to inefficencies and low labour productivity
Failures- Meeting Targets
Production increased yet many official targets were not met
Large-scale fraud by local administration allowed Stalin to claim it was 'over-fulfilled'
Local party officals sacked or demoted if failed to meet production targets
Due to this many lied about the amount they were producing, giving the impression that targets had been reached
Targets were about quantity not quality so consequencly large amounts of materials were produced but they were of such low quality they were useless
Focus of production not consumption, if it wasn't used after production, it was left to decay
Failures- Living and Working Conditions
Living standards improvements not part of plan, subsequentially:
Workers sustained by rations, meaning their diet was worse that under the NEP
Consumer goods practically disappeared and queuing became a everyday thing
Stalin introduced a seven day week, so sunday was just another worknig day
Working conditions deterioirated, with many peasants from the country died due to the factory work
Miners worked unsafe conditions
Labour discipline was harsh, lateness was a crime, strikes were outlawed and workers who broke machinery were named 'saboteurs' and were exiled to labour camps
Pressure was counter-productive as it meant low productivity
Many of the worker were prisoners forced to work to achieve and build the Soviet Union
Known by prison guards as 'white coal', had no rights and often left to stare to death
-Slave labour
Failures- The Abolition of the Free Market
One of Stalin's aims was to get rid of the free market and replace it with a centeralised planned economy
However it was unable to do so, and instead encouraged the formation of the black market
Shortage of consumer goods increased value, encouraging illegal trade of Vodka, Cigarettes, Footwear and Food
The black market was widespread, hard to stamp out by police, any that were cuaght were made a show of
'Speculators' were subject to 'show trials' in which they usually ended up in forced labour camps
Comments
No comments have yet been made