Law revision
- Created by: veerinder kaur
- Created on: 27-04-08 15:15
Sentencing
What does the crown court deal with?
more serious offences
And doesn't have what?
does not have any restrictions on the time limit of imprisonment or the maximum penalty for a fine.
Who does?
Magistrates do have these restrictions
sentencing
Penalties are set by who and for what?
Set by parliament to restrict the court's powers e.g a maximum of 7yrs imprisonment for theft doesn't depend on how much has been stolen
sentencing
what is maximum sentence?
life imprisonment
when is life imprisonment given?
has to be passed by judge for murder no other sentence is available
manslaughter and and **** can face life imprisonment
2nd serious or violent offence automatically brings in a life imprisonment
sentencing
When is minimum sentence available?
not available for first time offenders
minimum sentences for those who offend repeatedly
Aims of sentencing(retribution)
What is meant by retibution?
offender deserves punishment because of their unreasonable act
Aims of sentencing(retribution)
What should the punishment ensure?
That the punishment inflicted is in proportion to that offence committed
(in some crimes it isn't easy to produce an exact match between crime and punishment)
Example
judge in america got the victim of the burgulary to go the burgulars house and take items to that appropriate value with a law officer
Aims of sentencing(retribution)
What happens with tarrif sentences?
judge allowed only to impose a penalty within that tarrif range .
what can this cause?
injustice in certain cases where offenders can have a difficult financial situation if it is a case of fine
what can it also mean?
sentences for offenders are uninformed and remove discretion from judges
aims of sentencing(retribution)
What does retribution contain?
revenge between society and victim for the wrong done
aims of Sentencing(Denunciation)
What is denunciation?
expressing dissapproval of criminal activity, society condemns certain types of behaviour shows people that justice is being done
i.e
veiw of drink driving has changed because of the change in law , impose for heavier fines and banning from driving, viewed as an unacceptable behaviour.
aims of sentencing(Incapacitation or protection of
What does incapacitation mean?
that offender is not capable of re-offending i.e death penalty, hands cut off for thieves (in some countries) & in america incapacitate sex offenders to prevent from offending again.
punishment serve useful purpose
aims of Sentencing (incapacitation or protection o
whatare the minimum sentence for persistent offenders to protect the public from thier activities?
electronic tagging
exclusion orders to prevent offender from being in a place
curfew order, orders an offender to stay at a given address for a certain period time
aims of sentencing(individual deterrence)
what is individual deterrence?
preventing the offender from offending again through the fear of punishment i.e prison sentence or heavy fines
(offenders don't stop to consider the consequences of thier actions as they can be under the influene of drugs or alcohol)
aims of sentencing (individual deterrence)
Fear of detection has more of a what?
Deterrent effect, decrease in crime rates,
example
reduction in crime in london underground system when surveillance cameras were used
aims of sentencing (general deterrence)
What is general deterrence aiming at?
preventing potential offenders from offending again. aimed at reducing the level of crimes
aims of sentencing(general Deterrence)
Why is there general deterrence?
potential offenders might not care about severe punishment being passed on others
Aims of sentencing(general Deterrence)
what do judges try to ensure?
that potential offenders are aware of the level of punishment they can expect through the use of publicity
aims of sentencing(general Deterrence)
what is general deterrence in conflict with?
with retribution
why?
because it involves setting a particular punishment which can be very high in relation to the crime that has been done
i.e
raising of punishment for stealing a mobile phone on street from 6 mnths to 3 & half yrs.
(Least effective and leats fair principle of sentencing)
aims of sentencing(rehabilitation)
what does rehabilitation aim to do?
reform offender and rehabilitate the into society.
aims of sentencing(rehabilitation)
What does rehabilitation intend to change and how?
offenders behaviour by imposing the penalty so that he/she doesn't offend in the future.
important elementin what?
in philosophy for young offenders also used for adult offenders
Aims of sentencing(rehabilitation)
what are individualised sentences?
the individuals who have committed the same offence are given different sentences
why?
because the emphasis is on the individual offender
(direct contrast in tarrif sentences under retribution)
Aims of sentencing(rehabilitation)
What does individualised sentencing tend to do?
discriminate the underprivileged and offenders from poor home backgrounds as they are less likely to be seen as possible candidates for reform
aims of sentencing(rehabilitation)
what are persistent offenders less likely to respond to?
reformative sentences
(courts may take into consideration any previous failures to respond to previous sentences)
aims of sentencing(reparation)
what is reparation aimed at?
compensating the victim by the offender
what is there also?
projects that will bring together the victim and offenders so that th victim can take a direct reparation
aims of sentencing(reparation)
what should criminals do?
pay compensation to the victims and any other penalty that the judge thinks is appropriate. includes reparation to the society as a whole.
sentencing practice in the courts
What factors make an offence more serious?
-previous convictions of a similar offence
e.g defendant was on bail while committing that offence racial or religious hostility in relation to that offence disability or sexual orientation invovled in that offence
-if offender was in a position of trust and had abused it
sentencing practice in the courts
what happens if there is several defendants parts in a case?
the judge will want to know who played the greater and who was involved in planning it,
this will reflect the various sentences that each one of them recieves in relation to what part they played
sentencing practice in the courts
when is there a reduction in sentencing?
if there's a guilty plea made early enough in the courts proceedings
why is this view controversial by some people?
as they think if they have done the crime they should also do the time
sentencing practice in the courts
why is reducing a sentence due to guilty plea an advantage?
because it saves high costs, saves victims and witnesses to give evidence and saves time
sentencing practice in th courts
what happened when the publicity about cases where defendants had thier sentences reduced because they pleaded guilty?
government decided to change the law as it felt there was enough evidence to prove them guilty, therefore they shouldn't be rewarded for pleading guilty.
sentencing practice in courts
what does previous conviction consist of?
whether defendant has previous convictions of a related offence,
whether they have responded to previous sentences for crimes,
whether they were on bail while committing this crime
what will this decide?
sentence for punishment i.e minimum sentence or an automatic life sentence
sentcing practice in the courts
who are pre-sentence reports prepared by?
probation service
what will the courts do with these?
look at these and know about defendant's background to see why he/she has committed such a crime and if he/she will respond to a community-based penalty if the court was considering to give one.
sentencing practice in the courts
if offender suffers from an illness what is then prepared?
a medical report by a doctor.
what will this help the court do?
decide the best way to deal with the offender- the court has special powers when dealing with mental illness
sentencing practice in the courts
in cases where the court considers a fine for a penalty what must be taken into account?
financial circumstances and take this into account when setting the level of the fines
sentencing guidelines
correct level of sentencing for what?
certain types of offences
sentencing guidelines
when the sentencing guidelines council decides to make guidelines it must have to regard what?
need for consistency in sentencing
need to promote public confidence
cost of different sentences and sentences imposed by the courts
sentencing guidelines
what do the sentencing guidelines council guidline's include?
principles for serious factors in offences
principles of sentencing in domestic violence cases
sentencing for robberies
sentences in manslaughter even where public protection was involved
where there was provocation this still remains the critical factor in deciding the sentence.
powers of the courts
what are the4 main categoriesof sentences available to the courts?
community sentences
custodial sentences
fines
discharges
powers of the court
what are the additional orders the court have power to make?
compensation orders
and motoring offences such as disqualification from driving
powers of the court
what is a custodial sentence?
maximum sentence a court can give
ranges from a weekend imprisonment to life imprisonment
(young offenders will be kept seperate from adults if they were given a custodial sentence)
Powers of the court
when imposing a custodial sentence what must the court do?
state the reason for custodial sentence
in case of a magistrates' court?
they have to write the reason on a warrant of commitment and entered in the court register
Powers in the court
custodial cases are advised for which cases?
such as assaulting a police officer in execution of his duty
and burgulary of a residential property
Mandatory life sentences
Murder always carries what sentence?
life sentence
minimum number of years of imprisonment is stated by the judge.
minimum term is governed by
Mandatory life sentence
what do the starting points range from?
full life term down to 12 years
Madatory life sentences
when can the full life term only occur?
when there has been murder of previous persons by abduction or sexual motivations for victims
offender previously convicted by murder of child by abducting or sexual motivation for victim.
mandatory life sentences
cases with starting point of 30years include what?
where the murder is of a police or prison officer in the course of his duty
murder using a firearm or explosive
sexual or sadistic murder of an adult
racially or radically aggravated murder
mandatory life sentences
what is the time given where starting point of a murder offence is not given?
usually taken to be 15years
Mandatory life sentences
Offenders under the age of what have a starting point of...?
offenders under the age of 18 have a starting point of 12 years.
once the judge has decided on the starting there are ...
still aggravating factors that may affect the final sentence
Mandatory life sentences
aggravating factors include?
victim was vunerable because of age or disabilty or any mental or physical suffering inflicted on the victim before death
what do they increase?
minimum term ordered by the judge
mandatory life sentences
Mitigating factors include what?
offender had an intention to cause GBH, acted for self defence but was not enough
what sentence can the judge set for this?
minimum term less than the starting point
Mandatory life sentence
if individual over 18 and convicted for a second serious violent offence has to be what...?
sentenced for life imprisonment
judge can what?
set a minimum term that the offender should serve in prison
if there are exceptional circumstances...?
judge doesn't have to impose a life sentence
discretionary life sentences
serious offences like manslaughter,**** or robbery carries a maximum sentence of life imprisonment however...?
judge has descretionin sentencing and can givelesser sentence when appropriateeven fine or adischarge.
fixed term sentences
what is fixed term sentences?
sentences that have a set number of months or years
what does it depend on?
seriousness of crimes, max sentence for crime and previous convictions of offender
home detention curfew
why is the prisoner assessed?
to see if he/she is suitable for the curfew period
what is the period curfew increased with?
the length of sentences
home detention curfew
if no curfew is made then what must happen to the prisoner?
must serve half of the sentence before he/she can be released on licence
what does this do?
encourages released prisoners to re structure thier lives and prevents them from re-offending
prison population is reduced
extended sentences
what is meant by extended sentencing?
when serious offences(sex or violence) offenders are given a custodial sentence and an extended period , offender is at liberty on this licence
extended sentences
what can't the extended periods exceed?
10 yeards for sexual offence or 5 years for a violent offence
extended sentences
what is the idea behind this?
greater control over sexual offenders when they leave prison , they are required to register with the police so that it is known where they are living
intermittent custody
what is intermittent custody?
where prisoners spent the time in prison on weekends and on weekdays they're free
intermittent custody
why is the government trying to abolish intermittent custody?
because offenders were increasing the prison population and were blocking places for ordinary prisoners
minimum sentences
7 years is the minimum for offenders convicted of what?
dealing with class A drugs on three seperate occasions
judges can still impose lesser sentences on exceptional circumstances
minimum sentences
3 years is the minimum sentence for offender convicted of what?
burgulary on a 3rd time
judges can still decide lesser sentences on exceptional circumstances
suspended prison sentences
adult offenders suspended for what?
2 years imprisonment max
if in magistrates?
6mnths
suspended prison sentences
what is meant by suspended prison sentence?
the sentence does not take effect immediately, the court will set a time during which the sentence is suspended , this can be up to 2years
suspended prison sentences
if during the suspended period the offender doesn't commit a crime what happens?
they don't have to serve that sentence
suspended prison sentence
if the offender does commit a crime during the suspended period what happens?
the sentence is activated together with the new sentence for the new offence committed
suspended prison sentences
when are suspended sentences only given?
where a serious offence has been committed and
where custodial sentence would be appropriate but there are exceptional circumstances which justify the suspended sentence
suspended prison sentences
what is the idea for suspended sentencing and threat to prison?
prevents the offender from committing any further crimes
suspended prison sentences
what can a suspended sentence be combined with?
fines or compensation orders or requirements used in community order seen as soft option therefore rarley used by courts
sentences for young offenders
what do the courts aim for with sentences for young offenders?
need help rather than punishment
sentences for young offenders
what do the sentencing orders need to do?
keep offenders in the community
sentencing for young offenders
what do the different types of custodial sentences depend on when sentencing young offenders?
on age of offender
type of crime commited and
previous convictions
sentences for young offenders
what order is given to 12-21year olds?
detention training order
for under 15year olds this can only be done for who?
persistent offenders
sentences for young offenders
what can home secretary use and why?
longer periods of detention and training orders for 10-13 yeard olds if crime committed carried a maximum sentence of 14 years imprisonment
community sentences
what are previous community sentences now used as?
as requirements
what are requirements combined with?
the actual sentence
why can you mix and match requirements?
to fit restrictions or rehabilitation of offender's needs.
community sentences
what is unpaid work requirement?
when offender works from 240-300 hrs on a particular project organised by the probation service
one criticism?
number of hours is not enough, other countries who run similar schemes can impose much longer hours.
however...
re-offending rates are lower than for other community sentences
community sentences
what does prohibited activity require?
requires the offender not to do something from where he/she has caused trouble before
e.g carrying certain things or going to certain places
what does this prevent?
the offender from committing a crime he has done before
community sentences
what does curfew requirement require?
requires the offender to stay at a particular address for a certain period of time in a 24hr period.
what happens to the offender?
offenders are tagged by electronic tagging or satellites, quite exspensive but still less costly than keeping offender in prison
community sentences
what does the exclusion requirement prevent?
prevents the
offender from goin to a certain place at a particular time where they have committed a crime before
i.e shoplifters banned from shopping areas
how many for 16 years olds and over?
2 years
how long for under 16 year olds?
3 months
community sentences
what is supervision requirement?
where the offender is supervised by a probation officer
what is the maximum time?
3years
what must the offender do?
must attend appointments with supervising officer. promotes offender's rehabilitaion.
Fines
what is the most common way to dispose off a case in the magistrates?
fine the offender
fines
what is the maximum fine for an individual?
£5000
for a business?
£20 000
fines
what happens to offenders if they don't pay the fine (unpaid fines)
offenders are made to work (unpaid work) at a rate of £6 ph so the fine that is owned is remitted
what does this over come?
ineffective punishment and number of prisoners increase in prison
discharges
what is a conditional discharge?
offender is discharged on the condition that he/she doesn't commit a crime for a period of 3years max.
when is this used?
used when punishment is not necessary
if offender does offend again during that period what will happen?
a new sentence will be imposed and a new penalty for the new crime
discharges
what is an absolute charge?
where offender is charged without the penalty being imposed.
when will this happen?
when offender is technically guilty but morally blameless
disqualification from driving
what is disqualification from driving?
where defendant is charged of driving offence, he/she may be disqualified from driving
what does the length of disqualification depend on?
seriousness of crime
disqualification of driving
what does the 1st time drinking driving offence serve?
minimum is 12 mnths disqualification
what does the 2nd time drink driving offence serve?
minimum 3years disualification
disqualification of driving
what will courts also impose as well as disqualification?
courts will also impose a fine
what other crimes does disqualification of driving apply to?
burgulary where offnder has used a vehicle to commit the crime.
this power is rarely used
other powers available to courts
what happens when an offender recieves a compensation order or restitution order?
offender pays a sum of money to victim as compensation
what is the maximum payment in magistrates?
£5000
other powers available to courts
when does restitution occur?
when offender still has the property of the victim, the court makes an order to return it
other powers available to court
what is a deprivation order?
offender deprived from certain property.
other powers available to the court
what is a forfieture order?
allows court to take profits from criminals for up to 6 years before conviction
other powers available to courts
what must the judge have to set a deferred sentence?
a good reason for believing that offender's circumstancesare about to change, sentence may be deferred up to 6 mnths.
when should defer sentences occur?
where change in circumstances is such that punishment is not necessary or a lesser penalty be more suitable as a result of the change.
what does the offender have to do?
consent
young offenders
what does the term young offender include?
all offenders under the age of 21
young offenders
what is the main aim for sentencing youg offenders?
reformation and rehabilitation
young offenders
what types of sentences can be given to young offenders?
custodial sentences, community sentences, fines and discharges as with adult offenders but it is lesser for young offenders
young offenders
what age group are community sentences for?
16+
what age group are curfew orders for?
10+
young offenders
who are attendance centre orders supervised by and what does it include?
supervised by probation service and includes leisure activities and training
when is it set and for who?
various different hours per week and for different offenders depending on their age
Comments
No comments have yet been made